top of page

ONE NIAGARA: Twelve Municipalities. One Shared Future.

Writer: mmavridis
mmavridis
5 days ago
14 min read

By Maria Mavridis

The magnificent waters that tumble over the rocks at Niagara Falls do not belong solely to the City of Niagara Falls.


The breathtaking parklands, so beautifully maintained by Niagara Parks, do not belong to any one municipality.


And the historic streets of Niagara-on-the-Lake, its role as the first capital of Upper Canada, its historic courthouse, and one of North America’s oldest golf courses do not belong exclusively to those fortunate enough to call our town home.


They belong to every Canadian.


They are part of our collective history, our shared identity, and our responsibility to protect for generations to come.


Yet somewhere along the way, we in Niagara seem to have forgotten something rather important.


Municipal boundaries may exist on a map, but they should never define the boundaries of our responsibilities to one another.


We Are One Niagara

When homelessness increases in St. Catharines, it does not suddenly cease to be our concern because we live in Niagara-on-the-Lake.


When a family in Welland struggles to find housing, that struggle should matter to residents in Grimsby.


When a business in Niagara Falls succeeds, its success can create opportunities throughout the region.


And when someone from Niagara-on-the-Lake requires emergency medical care at a hospital in Niagara Falls, Welland, or St. Catharines, no one at the hospital doors asks them to turn around and return to their own municipality.


Because healthcare does not recognize municipal borders.


Neither does homelessness, economic development, transportation, tourism, or the need for good jobs.


So why do we continue to approach so many of these issues as though the borders on a municipal map are walls?


During my four years serving on Niagara-on-the-Lake Town Council, I made a conscious effort to build relationships with elected officials, municipal staff, and community leaders throughout Niagara.


Not simply because it was politically useful.


But because I understood that decisions being made in neighbouring municipalities would inevitably affect the residents I was elected to represent.


I wanted to understand the challenges facing Niagara Falls, St. Catharines, Welland, and our other communities.


I wanted to know the people making those decisions, hear their perspectives, and find opportunities to work together.


Because good municipal leadership should never begin and end at the town limits.


We are twelve municipalities, but we are one Niagara.


And that brings me to something I believe deserves far more attention, understanding, and cooperation than it has received.


Destination Niagara: A Provincial Vision for a Region That Has Yet to Fully See Itself as One


The Provincial Government has recognized something that we, as individual municipalities, have too often struggled to embrace.


Niagara is not simply a collection of twelve separate destinations competing for visitors, investment, infrastructure, and attention.


It is one extraordinary region.


One internationally recognized destination.

One interconnected economy.


And one opportunity to build something greater than any single municipality could accomplish on its own.


The Province’s Destination Niagara Strategy sets out a vision to strengthen Niagara as a world-class, year-round tourism destination.


It identifies opportunities involving tourism attractions, gaming and entertainment, wine and culinary tourism, arts and culture, and transportation.


The goal is not simply to bring people to Niagara Falls, have them photograph the waterfall, and send them home.


It is to encourage visitors to stay longer, experience more, spend money throughout the region, and discover everything Niagara has to offer.


And that brings me to one of the most misunderstood parts of the conversation.


“Just Like Vegas.” But Have You Actually Been to Las Vegas?


When Premier Doug Ford speaks about making Niagara “just like Vegas,” there seems to be an immediate assumption that he is talking exclusively about gambling.


More casinos. More slot machines. More gaming floors.


And with that assumption comes the inevitable outrage.


But I have a question.


Have you actually been to Las Vegas?

I have.

Twelve times, to be exact.

And here’s something that might surprise you.

I’m not a gambler.


What I love about Las Vegas has very little to do with what happens on a casino floor.


It’s the extraordinary variety of entertainment. The world-class shows.

The residency concerts featuring some of the biggest names in music. The restaurants offering flavours from every corner of the world.

The unique shopping experiences.

The architecture.

The energy.

And beyond the bright lights of the Strip?

The breathtaking Grand Canyon and natural wonders that draw visitors from around the world.


Las Vegas has managed to create something rather remarkable.


It has become a destination where gambling is only one part of the experience.


People travel there for conferences, concerts, culinary experiences, shopping, entertainment, and sightseeing.


They don’t all gamble.

They don’t have to.


And that is an important distinction when discussing the gaming and entertainment component of the Destination Niagara Strategy.


The opportunity is not simply to expand gaming floors. It is to consider how entertainment, hospitality, cultural attractions, restaurants, conferences, and other experiences can complement Niagara’s existing tourism offerings.


Now, am I suggesting that Niagara should become a replica of Las Vegas?


Absolutely not.


We have something Las Vegas cannot replicate.


We have Niagara Falls, internationally recognized natural beauty, extraordinary agricultural lands, world-class wineries, historic communities, and a place in the very foundation of Canada’s story.


We do not need to become Las Vegas.


We need to understand what Las Vegas has done successfully and determine how those lessons can help Niagara become the very best version of itself.


Because a world-class destination is not defined by one attraction.


It is defined by everything a visitor can experience once they arrive.


The International Traveller: What Happens After They See the Falls?

Imagine a family travelling from Europe.

They have saved their money, booked their flights, and planned a trip to Canada.


At the top of their list?

Niagara Falls.


They fly into Toronto, collect their luggage, rent a vehicle, and begin the journey down the QEW.


Depending on traffic, that journey can take hours.

Eventually, they arrive in Niagara Falls.

They stand before the rushing waters, take photographs, and experience the breathtaking natural wonder they have travelled thousands of kilometres to see.


And then?

What else is there to do?

Perhaps someone at their hotel mentions Niagara-on-the-Lake.


So they get back into their rental vehicle, drive down the Niagara Parkway, search for parking, walk along Queen Street, visit a few shops, have lunch, and then return to Niagara Falls for the evening.


The following day, perhaps they leave Niagara entirely.


We have attracted an international visitor to one of the most extraordinary regions in Canada, yet we have not necessarily given them a reason to explore everything else we have to offer.


And this is where I believe we are missing an enormous opportunity.


Niagara-on-the-Lake Is Not Yet the International Destination We Think It Is

This may not be a popular thing to say, but I believe it needs to be said.


Niagara-on-the-Lake is a wonderful destination.

But for many international travellers, it is not the destination that brought them to Canada.

Niagara Falls is.


Our town has built a strong tourism economy around visitors from Ontario, neighbouring provinces, and the northeastern United States.

Many travel three or four hours to visit us.


They come for a day, perhaps spend a night, enjoy our restaurants, wineries, theatre, shops, and historic charm, and then return home.


And we should be enormously proud of that.


But international tourism presents a different opportunity.


I have been fortunate enough to travel extensively throughout the world.


Actually, let me correct that.


I have worked hard throughout my life to ensure I could see the world.


And wherever I have travelled, when someone asks where I am from, my answer is always the same.


“Niagara-on-the-Lake.”

Almost inevitably, I receive a puzzled look.

So I follow it with:

“Near Niagara Falls. Close to Toronto.”


And suddenly, they know exactly where I mean.

That tells us something.


We live in one of Canada’s most historically significant communities, yet much of the world has never heard of us.


Think about that.


Our town has played an extraordinary role in the history of this country. Our streets, buildings, landscapes, and cultural institutions tell stories that deserve to be shared with the world.


Why wouldn’t we want international visitors to discover Niagara-on-the-Lake and the very history of Canada?

Why wouldn’t we want them to spend another night, attend a performance, visit a winery, dine at a local restaurant, and support the businesses that contribute to our local economy?


Why wouldn’t we want them to discover the other eleven municipalities that make Niagara extraordinary?


That is what destination development should be about.


Not simply attracting more people.


But giving people more reasons to stay.


We Cannot Complain About Tourism and Oppose Every Solution

Every summer, we hear the same complaints.

Too many vehicles.

Not enough parking.

Congested roads.

Busy sidewalks.

Residents feeling overwhelmed during peak tourism season.

These are legitimate concerns.

I have heard them for years, and I understand them.

But here is the contradiction.

We complain about the pressures created by seasonal tourism while simultaneously resisting many of the ideas intended to make tourism more sustainable.


What if we could spread visitation across twelve months rather than concentrating so much of our economic activity into a handful of summer weekends?


What if we could encourage visitors to stay longer, explore more communities, and travel throughout Niagara without needing a rental vehicle for every outing?


What if we could attract conferences in November, concerts in February, culinary experiences in March, and international visitors throughout the year?


Our restaurants still have staff to pay in January.

Our hotels still have mortgages, property taxes, and operating expenses in February.


Our shops still have rent to pay in November.

And our residents still need meaningful employment twelve months of the year.


A sustainable tourism economy cannot depend entirely on beautiful summer afternoons and long weekends.


We need to think about the next ten, twenty, and thirty years.

Not simply the next tourist season.


The question should not be how we stop Niagara from growing. It should be how we manage that growth responsibly, while protecting the communities we love.


The Niagara District Airport: An Opportunity Worth Understanding

Which brings me to another topic that has generated considerable opposition.

The Niagara District Airport.

The airport is jointly owned by three municipalities: Niagara-on-the-Lake, Niagara Falls, and St. Catharines.


The lands themselves are physically located in Niagara-on-the-Lake.


And because of that location, our residents understandably have concerns about what future expansion could mean for their community.


Noise. Traffic. Environmental impacts. Neighbourhood character.


Those concerns deserve to be heard and addressed.


But I would encourage residents and elected officials to do something before deciding that any expansion is unacceptable.


Read the Airport Master Plan. Understand what is actually being proposed. Ask questions.


There is an important difference between opposing a proposal after studying its implications and opposing the very idea of change.


A Perspective From Someone Who Actually Lives in Virgil

I have heard from residents living in Virgil who are concerned about the possibility of jets flying overhead should the Niagara District Airport expand.

And I understand those concerns.

After all, I live in Virgil myself.

But I think we need to put the conversation into perspective.

We are not necessarily talking about commercial jets arriving every hour, all day, every day.


The possibilities being discussed could involve something as modest as a commuter flight once a day, or perhaps every other day, depending on demand and the type of service ultimately introduced.


Those are illustrative possibilities, not confirmed flight schedules, and any actual proposal would need to be evaluated on its merits.


In my own experience, I couldn’t even tell you how many aircraft currently fly over my home.

The only time I really notice them is when I happen to be outside and hear one of the larger aircraft travelling in the direction of Buffalo.


That has been my personal experience living in Virgil.


Of course, I recognize that other residents may experience aircraft noise differently depending on where they live and the flight paths being used.


But I believe there is an important distinction between legitimate concerns about increased aircraft activity and assuming that airport expansion will automatically mean constant jets overhead.


We should be asking questions about projected flight frequency, aircraft types, operating hours, noise impacts, and how the surrounding community would be protected.


Those are reasonable questions that deserve factual answers.


What I don’t believe is reasonable is dismissing the opportunity entirely before understanding what is being proposed.


And there is something else worth remembering.

The Niagara District Airport was here long before many of us called this community home.


That doesn’t mean residents should have no say in its future.


Quite the opposite.


It means we have a responsibility to understand its history, consider its present role, and thoughtfully plan for what it could become.


Because municipal planning cannot be based solely on what is convenient for us today.

We need to consider what our children and grandchildren will need tomorrow.


We need to think about the businesses that will depend on regional accessibility, the jobs that could be created, and the opportunities that future generations deserve.


The airport was here long before we were. And we need to plan for a Niagara that will exist long after we are gone.

That, to me, is what responsible long-term planning looks like.

Imagine Arriving in Niagara, Not Toronto

Now imagine a different experience for an international visitor.


Instead of arriving in Toronto, renting a vehicle, and spending hours travelling along the QEW, imagine a future where suitable air connections allow that visitor to arrive directly at Niagara District Airport.


They land in Niagara-on-the-Lake.

From there, they could board a shuttle, take a taxi or Uber, or connect with regional transportation to reach their hotel anywhere in Niagara.


Perhaps they are staying in Niagara Falls.

Perhaps in St. Catharines, Lincoln, or Niagara-on-the-Lake.


Perhaps they are attending a conference in Welland.


And if those connections are convenient and reliable, they may never need to rent a vehicle at all.


Imagine the potential reduction in highway traffic if a meaningful number of visitors could arrive in Niagara without having to drive from Toronto.


That is not a guarantee, of course. It would depend on viable flight services, infrastructure, passenger demand, and ground transportation.

But it is an opportunity worth properly examining.


And consider this.

They would be landing in Niagara-on-the-Lake.

In our town.

At an airport that could serve the entire region.

Something I believe we should at least be proud enough to explore.


Airport planning is not simply about runways and aircraft.

It is about how people reach our region, how businesses attract investment, and whether Niagara can compete with other destinations for international tourism, conferences, and economic opportunities.


And that brings me to a real experience that illustrates why accessibility matters so much.

The Conference Niagara-on-the-Lake Lost

Recently, I assisted a local hotel with an application to host a major summit and conference in Niagara-on-the-Lake.

It was exactly the kind of opportunity our community needs.


The event was scheduled for late fall, when our tourism and hospitality businesses could use the additional activity.


It would have brought more than 500 attendees to our community.


The host hotel had the meeting rooms, presentation space, accommodations, and facilities required.


Additional attendees would have filled rooms at two other local hotels.


Our restaurants would have benefited.

Our shops would have welcomed visitors.

Our local businesses would have experienced an economic boost during a traditionally slower period.


By our estimates, the conference represented an opportunity approaching $1 million in local economic activity.

The hotel had met the requirements.

The facilities were there.

The hospitality was there.

The capacity was there.


But we did not win the bid.


Do you know why?


Transportation and accessibility.

Attendees would have been flying in from across Canada.

Think about that for a moment.

They would arrive at Toronto Pearson International Airport and then face another journey to Niagara.

Rent a vehicle.

Arrange transportation.

Or navigate train and transit connections that could add hours to their travel day.


For a conference organizer responsible for moving hundreds of delegates efficiently, that is a significant disadvantage.


And it cost our community an opportunity.

Not because we lacked the facilities.

Not because our hotels were inadequate.

Not because Niagara-on-the-Lake was an undesirable destination.


But because getting people here was too complicated.


We potentially lost close to $1 million in local economic activity because our region could not offer the convenient transportation access the conference required.


Now multiply that opportunity by the number of conferences, conventions, corporate retreats, international meetings, and special events that could consider Niagara if accessibility were improved.


Think of the hotel rooms filled in November.

The restaurant tables occupied in February.

The employees working additional shifts in March.


The businesses benefiting outside the traditional tourism season.


And then ask yourself one very important question.


How can we call ourselves a global destination if we cannot make it easy for people to get here?


The Airport Is Not Just About Tourists

Let’s remove the international leisure traveller from the conversation entirely.

Consider business travel.

Conferences.

Professional associations.

Corporate retreats.

Educational summits.

Arts and cultural events.

Sporting competitions.


These are economic opportunities that can bring visitors to Niagara throughout the year.

And unlike some leisure travellers, conference organizers often make decisions based on practical considerations.


How easily can delegates arrive?


How long does it take to reach their hotel?


Can hundreds of attendees travel efficiently?


Can they return home without losing an entire additional day?


These are not small details.

They can determine whether a destination wins or loses a major event.


Improving access to Niagara could help our hotels, restaurants, attractions, and local businesses compete for opportunities that currently go elsewhere.


Does that mean every proposed airport expansion should automatically receive approval?


No.


Does it mean residents should surrender their right to question environmental impacts, flight paths, noise, costs, or the financial viability of expansion?


Absolutely not.


But it does mean that we should be willing to examine the opportunities alongside the risks.


We should be asking what level of air service makes sense for Niagara, what infrastructure would be required, how it would be funded, and how surrounding communities would be protected.


And perhaps most importantly, we should be asking whether the economic benefits could extend across all twelve municipalities.


Because an airport physically located in Niagara-on-the-Lake does not need to exist solely for Niagara-on-the-Lake.


Just as Niagara Falls does not belong solely to Niagara Falls.


Regional infrastructure should be evaluated through a regional lens.

Growth Must Benefit the People Who Live Here

Now, does all of this mean I support every proposal contained within the Province’s Destination Niagara Strategy?


Of course not.


A strategy of this magnitude deserves thoughtful scrutiny, meaningful public consultation, and careful consideration of its effects on the people who live here.


More visitors should not automatically mean more vehicles travelling our roads.


It should not mean overwhelming our historic districts, sacrificing agricultural lands, or placing additional pressure on infrastructure that already requires investment.


And it certainly should not mean measuring success solely by the number of people who arrive.


More visitors are not necessarily better visitors.

Longer stays, greater local spending, year-round employment, and a more sustainable tourism economy should be our priorities.


Transportation must be central to that conversation.


If we are serious about attracting international visitors and encouraging them to explore the entire region, then we must provide practical ways for them to travel between our communities without depending entirely on private vehicles.


That means examining regional transit connections, rail service, airport accessibility, and transportation systems that serve residents as well as visitors.


We should be at the table helping shape those decisions, not standing outside the room complaining that they are being made.


Our Greatest Competition Is Not Each Other

For too long, Niagara municipalities have approached economic development and tourism through the lens of individual municipal interests.


Who receives the investment?

Who gets the visitors?

Who collects the revenue?

Who receives the recognition?


Those questions matter, but they should not be the only questions we ask.


We should also be asking what benefits the entire region.


What creates sustainable employment?

What strengthens our agricultural industry?

What supports our arts, culture, and heritage?


What makes Niagara a better place to live, work, raise a family, and retire?


Because the success of Niagara Falls does not diminish Niagara-on-the-Lake.


The success of St. Catharines does not diminish Welland.

And investment in one municipality can create opportunities far beyond its borders.

We do not need to erase our individual identities to recognize our collective potential.


Twelve Municipalities. One Niagara.

I have always believed that public service carries a responsibility greater than the boundaries of the office we hold.


During my four years on council, I saw firsthand how interconnected our communities truly are.

I also saw how much more we could accomplish if we approached regional challenges with cooperation rather than competition.


The Destination Niagara Strategy is not perfect. No strategy of this scale ever is.


But its greatest opportunity may have very little to do with tourism numbers, new attractions, or international marketing campaigns.


Perhaps its greatest opportunity is to finally encourage Niagara to see itself as one region.

To recognize that the waterfall belongs to our collective heritage.


That our historic communities tell a shared Canadian story.


That our hospitals serve our neighbours regardless of their postal codes.


That our airport, transportation networks, and economic opportunities should be considered for the benefit of the entire region.


And that the challenges facing one Niagara municipality should concern every one of us.

We can preserve what makes each of our twelve municipalities unique while recognizing that our future is connected.


The Province has presented a vision.


Now it is up to us to ensure that vision respects our communities, protects our heritage, supports our residents, and delivers meaningful benefits across Niagara.


Because Niagara is not twelve competing destinations.

We are one Niagara.

And perhaps it is time we started acting like it.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page